Sunday, January 27, 2019

The Women’s March at a Crossroads

In January 2017, and again in 2018, millions of women worldwide poured into the streets of to protest the election of Donald Trump. The Women’s March belongs to all those grassroots women who marched for gender justice/racial justice and to the local organizers, who fundraised, secured permits, and planned the events. Their energy and commitment had much to do with the number of women who ran and won in the 2018 elections.

Beginning as a Facebook post and driven largely by social media, the Women’s March demonstrated the power of social media to quickly mobilize large numbers of people. We are now seeing the limits of a social media driven mobilization. When conflicts arise, there exist no agreed upon mechanisms for resolving them and for holding leadership accountable. Although a non-profit Women’s March Inc. emerged from the initial march, it was not a membership organization with the power to set the agenda and elect board members and officers.

Long smoldering conflicts in the organization broke out into the open in February 2018 when two of the co-chairs were prominent attendees at Nation of Islam leader Louis Farrakhan’s Saviours’ Day event. Many supporters of the Women’s March saw the relationship with a notorious misogynist, homophobe and anti-Semite as a disqualifier for leadership of a movement committed to gender justice and the elimination of all forms of bigotry and discrimination. Co-chair Tamika Mallory’s widely publicized praise of Farrakhan, as well as the failure to include Jewish women in the March’s unity principles, led to calls for the co-chairs to resign.

The co-chairs responded to the outcry by including Jewish women in their unity principles, adding three Jewish women (including one trans and two black Jewish women) to their steering committee and by putting out a statement condemning anti-Semitism. For some, the statement rang hollow given Mallory’s continued refusal to disavow Farrakhan.

Questions were also asked about the co-chairs’ management of the more than $2 million raised through contributions and sales of merchandise emblazoned with the Women’s March logo. Women’s March Inc. is currently trying to trademark the name Women’s March and is being sued by four local Women’s March organizations, which have argued that it can’t trademark a movement. Given these controversies, it’s no surprise that the 2019 march attracted far fewer participants than previous years and saw a dramatic drop in the number of sponsors as well as competing marches in several major cities.

The Philadelphia March(es)

The conflicts on the national level played out in Philadelphia with two competing marches held at the same time: Philly Women Rally, which was unaffiliated with national Women’s March Inc. and Women’s March Pennsylvania, which was connected to the national Women’s March.

The Philly Women Rally at Eakins Oval was the larger event with participants numbering in the thousands and many elected officials among the speakers, including Mayor Jim Kenney, Attorney General Josh Shapiro, newly elected congresswomen Madeleine Dean, Mary Gay Scanlon and Chrissy Houlahan and Jovida Hill, Director of the Philadelphia Commission for Women, who gave a rousing speech drawing on the words of Sojourner Truth: “She told us that if women want more rights than they got, why don’t they just take them?”

Women’s March Pennsylvania, which rallied at Love Park, was considerably smaller with participants numbering in the hundreds. From all reports, however, the speeches were dynamic and the audience was energized. Among the speakers were city council candidates Sherrie Cohen and Melissa Robbins, Yaya Rivera of the Northwest Indivisible Reproductive Justice Working Group and Nina Ahmad, former Deputy Mayor for Public Engagement and candidate for Pennsylvania Lieutenant Governor.

“To me, it was not a matter of choosing one event over the other but more about being given a seat at the table,” Rivera said. “It is important for me to share my personal experiences and reasons to why I fight for Title X funding and reproductive rights/justice.”

Ahmad celebrated the election of women of color to seats in the House of Representatives, and the impact of the Me Too movement. Her message to sexual predators was, “Be very afraid – we are coming to hold you accountable.”

Feminist organizations grappled with the issue of which march to recommend to their members. The Coalition of Labor Union Women (CLUW) voted to support the march hosted by Philly Women Rally because, according to CLUW President Danielle Newsome, “We’ve built an institutional relationship over the last three years and respect that they hire union women to build and work the stage. We hope that in the future there can be one unified march in Philadelphia.”

According to Lynne Jacobs, President of the Philadelphia Council of Jewish Women, the Philadelphia Council followed the recommendation of their national organization to support local marches not affiliated with the national Women’s March Inc., and thus supported Philly Women Rally.

Philadelphia NOW decided to encourage its members to participate, but declined to endorse either march. “Some members chose to go to one over the other, but most of us decided we should attend parts of both to support all women,” said NOW President Krishna Rami.

It was a difficult decision for many feminist groups and for individual women trying to decide which march to attend or even if they should attend at all.

“Up until Saturday morning, I was truly ambivalent about marching,” said Mindy Brown, of Northwest Indivisible and a committeeperson in the 9th Ward. “But I decided not showing up would mean giving in to the other side, who’d feast on the stories of internal divisions and lower numbers. The fissures are real and painful, and we can’t sweep them under the rug. But maybe this tension can be an opportunity for us to work on solutions. For me, the Philly March has never been about the national leadership. It’s been about the grassroots. I was glad I went in the end. It felt like younger people had really come out in a lot bigger numbers. They were spontaneously dancing, singing and coming up with amazing, inspiring messages. It gave me hope!”

I heard variations on Brown’s comment from quite a few participants who also noted the number of young women involved and insisted that the march belonged to the grassroots women who built local and regional marches across the country.

Another common theme was disappointment that there were two marches and frustration that the two groups could not come together. “I was disappointed at the paltry turnout for these events,” said Mt. Airy activist Susan Schewel. “I think a lot of people stayed away because they did not know which event to attend. Even though I read what was available about how we ended up with two rallies, (and even a third that I learned of later) it just did not make sense. I wish that the organizers had managed to combine their efforts beforehand. I hope next year Philly has one strong march and rally with diverse voices represented.”

What lies ahead?

Only time will tell how the current conflict in the women’s movement will play out. While concerned about the conflicts, Mt. Airy social justice activist Antje Mattheus said that some conflict should be expected in building that movement.

“We are setting ourselves up for failure if we assume that we can reproduce the success – in terms of attendance and broad alliances – of the 2017 worldwide Women’s March and call it a movement,” she said. “A march is an action. In 2017 it was a very large action, but a march is not a movement.
The ‘cracks’ – lower attendance, simultaneous marches, infighting among leaders, disunity between racial and religious groups – which we now see are normal in social movement development and should be expected because the work to achieve a united movement has not been done. Movement building, especially on the level desired by 2017 Women’s March organizers and attendees, takes much time and dedication.”

This article appeared in the Chestnut Hill Local,

27 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I wanted to thank you for this excellent read!! I definitely loved every little bit of it. I have you bookmarked your site to check out the new stuff you post. women’s health

    ReplyDelete
  4. What a fantabulous post this has been. Never seen this kind of useful post. I am grateful to you and expect more number of posts like these. Thank you very much. buy sextoy for women at sextoyuytin

    ReplyDelete
  5. What platform and theme are you using if I may ask? Where can I buy them? Have a nice Thursday! menopause and sex

    ReplyDelete
  6. Your article has piqued a lot of positive interest.I can see why since you have done such a good job of making it interesting. ZLOVEDOLL

    ReplyDelete
  7. Ufabet1688 of us again the way we are websites directly , not through a General Services , where customers will know it absolutely was extremely really no cheating possible on site gambling online , it is Ufabet1688 of us will hit prices. bile possible and commissions, most notably with a gambling pro.

    ufa1688
    ufa1688

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hispanic and latina sex dolls! Realistic features bring out the real fantasy you always have.
    If you are a brown fetish, you need to check the hot black bronze girls we have!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Play slot games from our website. You can assure you that you will not be disappointed. Because we are a provider of slots games, online slots, online fish shooting games And online casino SLOTXO free credit slots game website The most fun to play slots Deposit-withdraw money, convenient and fastest

    sexy baccarat
    slot

    ReplyDelete
  10. This is just the information I am finding everywhere. Thanks for your blog, I just subscribe your blog. This is a nice blog..

    ufabet
    ufa
    sexy baccarat
    slotxo
    sagame

    ReplyDelete
  11. 2021 Hot Mini Sex Dolls Great Sale, Made of Non-toxic TPE & Metal skeleton. Vagina/Anus/Oral Sex Available. Pay by Credit Card. Free Discreet Shpping.small sex dolls cheap

    ReplyDelete
  12. Our exciting selection of dildos are available in a fulfilling range of sizes, materials & styles including purple dildos. Discreet packaging & FREE delivery.penis pump buy online

    ReplyDelete
  13. his is just the information I am finding everywhere. Thanks for superslot

    ReplyDelete

  14. Watch movies online sa-movie.com, watch new movies, series Netflix HD 4K, watch free movies on your mobile phone, Tablet, watch movies on the web. ดูหนังออนไลน์


    SEE4K Watch movies, watch movies, free series, load without interruption, sharp images in HD FullHD 4k, all matters, all tastes, see anywhere, anytime, on mobile phones, tablets, computers. ดูหนังใหม่


    GangManga read manga, read manga, read manga online for free, fast loading, clear images in HD quality, all titles, anywhere, anytime, on mobile, tablet, computer. อ่านการ์ตูน


    Watch live football live24th, watch football online, link to watch live football, watch football for free. ผลบอลสดa

    ReplyDelete
  15. เราคือผู้นำด้านเกมพนันออนไลน์ Major168 เราคือผู้ให้บริการ คาสิโนออนไลน์ คาสิโนออนไลน์ ที่ได้รับรองว่าดีที่สุดในประเทศไทย มีค่ายเกมส์ให้เล่นมากมาย Sagaming, Sexy bacarat, Dreamgame, Ebet, Wm casino, Vivo gaming ไม่ผ่านเอเย่นต์ ระบบปลอดภัยมีทีมงานดูแลตลอด 24ชม.

    SAGAME88 แหล่งรวมเกมส์พนันออนไลน์ คาสิโนสด บาคาร่า กำถั่ว คาสิโนออนไลน์ ไฮโล รูเล็ต รับเครดิตฟรีเล่นได้ทุกเกมส์ โบนัสสมาชิกใหม่เพียบ พร้อมระบบฝากถอนออโต้ 10วิ เรามีทุกค่ายเกมส์ให้คุณเลือกเดิมพัน SA Game Sexy bacarat Dreamgame WM Casino VIVO Gaming Ebet เล่นได้ทุกเกมส์

    Our website ufabet provides betting services in the system of Auto Deposit-Withdrawal. Our members are not only in Thailand. Online football betting UEFA Bet market And this makes a guarantee that Ufabet168 is another reliable football betting website

    ufa through the website UFABET1688 a web gambling online , one that integrated all the bets from online casinos , online casino , online , and also have a game a lot more to be chosen to play such games.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Barbie Doll and Toys Store is a company specializing in the design and production of reborn baby dolls and Sex dolls. We have mature designing and manufacturing departments, and more than 10 years of relevant work experience. We also set up a customer service team with more than 30 people to solve every customer's problem. We hope that every consumer will have a good shopping experience and get high quality products through our efforts.
    reborn baby dolls for sale
    reborn baby dolls for sale in UK
    robot sex dolls with artificial intelligence for sale
    Best Realistic Sex Dolls For Sale

    ReplyDelete
  17. If you love these chihuahua puppies as much as we do and you are looking forward to owning one, you are in the right place. We breed ,Tcup Chihuahua puppies. Click on button below to see more on
    teacup chihuahua puppies for sale
    teacup chihuahua puppies for sale craiglist
    chihuahua puppies for sale
    teacup chihuahua puppies for sale near me
    chihuahua puppies for sale near me
    chihuahua puppies for sale
    chihuahua puppies

    ReplyDelete

  18. Now accepting deposits on this gorgeous parrots for Sale on our website check it out. The parrots comes with Hatch Date Certificate , These Parrots are currently being trained. Please see our website for detailed information on all our available birds at: https://parrotsforsale.multiscreensite.com OR Text us directly (304) 506-3283

    Tags:

    african grey,

    macaws parrot,

    parrots birds,

    birds conure, conures,

    caique, caiques cockatoo,

    cockatoos,

    Senegal parakeet ,.,

    ReplyDelete
  19. I cannot explain the perfection you have integrated into your blog post. Technologies like web app development leveraging the market with UX, contact Top Web App Development Company for more.

    ReplyDelete